GroupImage
Galloway and Collens PLLC
26705 Woodward Avenue, Suite 200
Huntington Woods, MI 48070
(248) 545-2500
scott@gallowaycollens.com and www.gallowaycollens.com


It's not always easy being green


Homebuyers, businesses, and residential and commercial tenants are all showing interest in "green" buildings these days – those designed to save energy, use sustainable materials and have less of an impact on the environment.

Many buyers and renters are willing to pay a little more for a green building – especially if they can recoup their money through energy savings.

But if you're serious about going green, think carefully about the legal aspects. You'll want to make sure the building really is as green as it claims, and that you get what you pay for.

Many homebuyers are willing to pay more for a green house, or are inclined to choose a green house if all other things are equal.

About 10% of all new homes are expected to feature environmentally friendly construction by 2010 – up from only 2% in 2007, according to the National Association of Home Builders.

Green features can include:

• Energy-efficient appliances.

• Extra insulation to reduce heating costs.

• Solar panels or shingles.

• Thicker or double-pane windows, or windows with a metallic coating to block the sun's heat.

• A rainwater-capture system.

• Low-flow toilets.

• Building materials that are recycled, or are produced locally to reduce transport costs.

If these things are important to you, then it might be worth specifically mentioning them in any contract with a seller or builder. If the seller has made specific promises about energy savings, it's a good idea to get these in writing.

In commercial leasing, there's been a growing interest in so-called "green leases," which are designed to reduce overall energy costs.

Traditionally, most commercial leases either include basic energy costs in the rent, or require the tenant to pay for its own heat, electricity, etc.

Slightly more than half the commercial leases in the U.S. are "gross" leases, meaning the energy costs are included in the rent. The problem with this from a green perspective is that it creates no incentive for the tenant to reduce energy use, since the tenant doesn't have to pay for it.

In a "net" lease, where the tenant pays for energy use, there's an incentive for the tenant to save energy, but there's no incentive for the landlord to adopt building-wide changes that will reduce energy consumption, such as better insulation, thicker windows, or roofs that reduce building heat in the summer.

 

So the idea of a green lease is to create an incentive for both parties to reduce energy costs. For instance, a tenant might agree to pay for its own heat and electricity, if the landlord will agree to improve the overall building's energy efficiency. Or a landlord might agree to assume the energy costs if the tenant engages in certain practices or meets certain targets for reducing energy consumption.

There are many reasons why both parties might want a green lease. A landlord might want a tenant to pay for its own energy usage in return for retrofitting the building to be more environmentally friendly, because that will pay for changes that will make the building more attractive to other tenants. Or a commercial tenant might have a "green" reputation in the marketplace, and want the landlord's help in creating a message about how the tenant engages in sustainable practices.

Many owners and builders are now applying for LEED certification for their buildings. LEED stands for "Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design." It's a rating system developed by the U.S. Green Building Council that awards points for various environmentally friendly ways in which a building is constructed.

A building must have at least 26 out of a possible 69 "points" in order to be LEED-certified. A building that has a higher number of points may be certified at a Silver, Gold, or Platinum level.

A building can get points for being sited near public transportation, reducing internal energy use, offering racks and changing areas for bicyclists, having water-efficient landscaping, using local or recycled construction materials, improving indoor air quality, etc.

LEED-certified buildings are often attractive to tenants because they reduce energy costs and improve tenants' health and comfort.

Many building contracts now specify that a building must be certified at a certain LEED level. If this is important to you, you'll want to be very clear in any contract exactly what level is required, when it must be accomplished, and what the consequences are if the building doesn’t get certified at the intended level.


Line


Condo could prohibit religious displays on doorways


A condominium association can prohibit owners from displaying any objects on or in front of their doorways – including Christmas decorations and crucifixes, says a federal appeals court in Chicago.

In this case a woman sued because the condo rule had prohibited her from placing a traditional Jewish mezuzah on her doorpost. She claimed this amounted to religious discrimination.

But the court said that the rule was valid as long as it was a blanket ban on all objects, religious or otherwise.

While a condo board could not ban

 

only religious articles – because this would be discrimination – the board in this case wasn't discriminating, because it banned all objects including non-religious articles such as photos, artwork and sports banners.

Nor did the board have a legal duty to make an exception for religious articles.

However, the court's ruling only discussed the woman's claim under the federal Fair Housing Act. Other state or local laws might require an association to accommodate a religious observance.


Line


Landlord can’t be sued for one tenant's harassment of another


Even if a black tenant's family was subjected to racist comments and verbal abuse by a white tenant’s family, the black tenant can't sue the landlord, says the Ohio Supreme Court.

The black tenant claimed she kept an extensive record of the harassment and reported each incident in writing to the landlord. However, the landlord (a public housing authority) allegedly didn't do anything.

An Ohio law prohibits landlords from discriminating against tenants because of race. However, the landlord in this case didn't itself harass the black tenant, the court observed. And the law doesn't say

 

that a landlord has to prevent other people from mistreating a tenant.

Despite this court's ruling, this is a very difficult area for landlords. Landlords in many states may have a legal duty to protect their tenants' safety and peace of mind – not to mention a moral obligation and a strong business interest in preventing this sort of misbehavior. On the other hand, it can sometimes be difficult for landlords to be sure of the facts when different sides tell different stories. We will be happy to assist you if you are facing a difficult situation with a tenant conflict.


Line


You might be paying too much in property taxes


Many people are paying too much in property taxes, and may be eligible for a reduction or a refund.

Property taxes are calculated by taking the assessed value of your home and multiplying it by the local property tax rate. But since home prices in so many areas have decreased recently, it's possible that the assessed value of your home is now larger than its actual value – in which case you might be entitled to a tax break.

So it's worth looking carefully at your bill to see what your assessed value is, and whether it still makes sense.

In some areas that are suffering from a sharp housing price decline, tax authorities are proactively reviewing valuations. Los Angeles County recently reduced its assessments of 128,000 homes, with an average tax savings of $750.

In addition to the fact that home prices have dropped in most parts of the country, there can also be mistakes in an assessment.

Often, an assessor doesn't actually inspect the property; he or she just looks at it from outside or works from a written description. There have been cases where the assessment was based on an incorrect square footage or number of bedrooms, and cases where a half-bathroom was assumed to be a full one and a screened porch was treated as a year-round living space.

 

If your assessment is several years old, it might not take into account changes in the neighborhood or surrounding development that have affected your property and reduced its value.

How can you prove your case? One way is to hire an appraiser. Another is to find a number of comparable houses in your area and look up their assessed value, to see if your assessment is out of line.

In some areas, you can discuss the issue directly with an assessor, but in other areas this isn't allowed. In either case, you might end up have to file an appeal of your assessment.

Nationwide, assessment appeals are successful and reduce property owners' taxes between 30 and 50 percent of the time, according to the National Taxpayers Union.

If you think your assessment is too high, it's best to act quickly; there are often strict deadlines for challenging a valuation.


Line


Credit card companies make it harder to get a mortgage


Some people are finding it harder to get a mortgage these days...because of their credit card company.

Why? Because credit card companies have reacted to the recent economic downturn by reducing many cardholders' credit limits and cancelling inactive cards. The companies' goal is to reduce the risk of non-payment.

The problem is that whether you can get a mortgage – or how good the terms of that mortgage are – depends to a great extent on your credit score. And a major factor in your credit score is the ratio of how much you've borrowed to your available credit.

When a credit card company cancels a card or slashes your credit limit, it increases this ratio, which can in turn lower your credit score.

Banks have been getting stingier for a while. Even in the second quarter of 2008, almost two-thirds of U.S. banks said they tightened their standards for credit card loans. And the situation appears to have gotten worse since.

Here are some "alarm bells" that can cause a bank to lower your credit limit:

• Living in an area with worsening unemployment or plummeting home values.

• Suddenly charging necessities to a credit card, such as groceries, utility

 

bills or insurance premiums.

• Running up high balances, taking cash advances, sending smaller payments, or not paying the bill in full when you have a history of doing so.

Of course, you can't do much about the place you live in. But if you’re concerned about your credit score, it's a good idea to avoid the other "alarm bells" above.

It's also a good idea to make an occasional small charge to your inactive cards, just to keep them active. And if your company does reduce your credit limit, call and ask why, and see if you can talk them out of it.

Note: If you have a "rewards" card and you regularly charge groceries and other necessities in order to get a card benefit, you don't need to stop. What the companies are concerned about is a sudden change in your typical habits.



This newsletter is designed to keep you up-to-date with changes in the law. For help with these or any other legal issues, please call our firm today.

The information in this newsletter is intended solely for your information. It does not constitute legal advice, and it should not be relied on without a discussion of your specific situation with an attorney.

38.103.63.61/5.93